Instapundit » Blog Archive » BILL MCMORRIS: How The Supreme Court Created The Student Loan Bubble: It all starts with Griggs v….

The lie that props up our Big Education regime is that the GI Bill, which paid for World War II veterans to attend college, produced the upward mobility and economic boom of the postwar period. It’s a heartwarming story, the veteran who would have been a dust farmer but for the grace of government generosity. But it just isn’t true. Only one out of every eight returning veterans attended college. The rest, the vast majority, benefited from something even more egalitarian: aptitude testing. The format favors raw talent above all else, allowing companies to hire high-potential candidates from any background and groom them to fit the company’s needs.

These tactics came to commerce from a familiar source.The armed services were forced to process hundreds of thousands of recruits during the war, and in order to filter and assign soldiers, the government developed aptitude tests. Businesses witnessed the U.S. defeat the two most efficient peoples known to man, thought there must be something to this whole testing thing, and followed suit. The chief hiring metric in the postwar era was not whether someone had a degree, but whether he had the aptitude that would enable him to succeed. Every industry from blue-blooded high finance to immigrant-heavy manufacturing employed testing to determine who would rise through the ranks, regardless of lineage, heritage, or education. Testing enabled men who set out to be blue-collar workers to ascend based solely on their ability. . . .

via Instapundit » Blog Archive » BILL MCMORRIS: How The Supreme Court Created The Student Loan Bubble: It all starts with Griggs v…..

Of course, the government is still allowed to use aptitude testing. That’s what the ASVAB test is. It’s right there in the title- Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery.

But because hiring by aptitude could, and sometimes did, have a disparate impact on minorities, particularly African Americans, the Supreme Court ruled it an unconstitutional infringement on civil rights. That’s a case I’d really like to see the court revisit and correct.

3 thoughts on “Instapundit » Blog Archive » BILL MCMORRIS: How The Supreme Court Created The Student Loan Bubble: It all starts with Griggs v….”

  1. No we read resumes and make guesses. Hiring someone is expensive, more so in the government, when it takes 6 months to a year to hire someone.

  2. Until 1981 it was possible to get a federal civil service job up to GS 5 (EX; Payroll Clerk) by taking the PACE (Professional and Administrative Career Exam). Now, education above high school is required instead. Aptitude? Not necessary. Credentials? Necessary.

Comments are closed.